Mustard BBQ Sauce | The Choosy Eater

This put up could include affiliate hyperlinks. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please learn my disclosure.

Tangy but candy, home made Mustard BBQ Sauce has a yellow mustard base that’s sweetened with honey and brown sugar. It’s scrumptious slathered on all the things from pulled pork to veggie burgers to rooster sandwiches. This barbecue sauce recipe is certain to turn out to be a favourite!

Mustard-based BBQ sauce goes by many names – Carolina gold sauce, Carolina mustard BBQ sauce / Carolina mustard barbecue sauce, Carolina mustard sauce, SC BBQ, or southern gold BBQ sauce.

It’s fashionable in South Carolina, particularly Charleston, therefore its identify. Conventional barbecue sauce is tomato-based, whereas mustard barbecue sauce has a yellow mustard base with a small quantity of tomato paste or ketchup.

Should you’ve been to a BBQ or a BBQ restaurant or BBQ joint in South Carolina, chances are high you’ve seen a number of yellow barbecue sauces (anyplace else and also you’d doubtless see crimson sauce!).

Such issues could be thought of blasphemy in lots of sections of the US the place barbecue sauce is a faith (I’ve learn some very sturdy opinions on social media!), however in North Carolina, this sauce is the holy grail! (I don’t take accountability for anybody’s emotions on this subject, examine my phrases of service, hah!) There are numerous sorts of barbecue sauce on the market (do you know there’s even white barbecue sauce?), and this is only one of them.

Should you’ve by no means tried any mustard bbq sauce recipes, you’re going to like this nice recipe. Fireplace up the gasoline grills or seize your charcoal!

This tasty sauce is heavenly drizzled on grilled rooster (or baked complete rooster), smoked pork, pulled pork, tofu, jackfruit, and pulled rooster. I’m no native South Carolinian, however I might drink it from the squeeze bottle if it have been socially acceptable. It’s simply that good!

You don’t need to hit up BBQ eating places to take pleasure in one of the best home made BBQ sauce. It’s straightforward to make at dwelling with primary elements like mustard, apple cider vinegar, and brown sugar.

This honey mustard bbq sauce recipe is a cinch to make with no cooking required. Simply combine all of the elements collectively, pour into an hermetic container, and let the flavors develop in a single day. Should you can’t wait that lengthy, I don’t blame you! It’ll nonetheless style scrumptious immediately, nevertheless it’s finest to make it the night time earlier than if doable.

👩🏽‍🍳 Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Pantry Substances: This mustard vinegar BBQ sauce is made with all budget-friendly pantry elements. You would possibly even have all the things you want already! If not, a fast journey to the grocery retailer is a good suggestion. It’s best to have the ability to discover these easy elements at any grocery retailer.
• Versatile: My South Carolina mustard BBQ sauce goes with just about each meal. Slather on a few of this scrumptious mustard BBQ sauce earlier than cooking and/or use it as a condiment on the desk. This barbecue sauce is a good way so as to add loads of taste to your meals.
• Child-Pleasant: In contrast to some tomato-based barbecue sauces, this sauce is just not spicy. Any child who likes mustard will love this mustard primarily based BBQ sauce.
• Particular Weight-reduction plan Pleasant: This nice sauce is of course gluten-free and dairy-free. Swap the honey for agave syrup to make it vegan if wanted!

Newest Recipe Video!

🥘 Substances

Store your pantry and see you probably have the elements for this South Carolina mustard sauce beneath! If not, your native grocery retailer ought to have all the things you want. See the recipe card on the backside of the put up for dietary info.

• Yellow Mustard: That is the primary ingredient, and if you wish to hold it traditional, yellow mustard is the one approach to go! Yellow mustard has simply the correct quantity of tang to steadiness out the candy. Be sure to don’t use dijon mustard – you gained’t get the precise taste on this scrumptious sauce recipe.
• Brown Sugar And Honey: The mix leaves you with a candy however honey-like taste. Brown sugar incorporates molasses which has a caramel-like taste good for BBQ sauce recipes.
• Apple Cider Vinegar: Apple cider vinegar has a slight sweetness and an acidic punch I really like for sauce recipes.
• Worcestershire Sauce: You gained’t style this ingredient however two tablespoons will give this recipe a savory, umami style and a great punch of taste. If you’re vegan (or a vegetarian who doesn’t eat fish), make certain to get a vegan-friendly Worcestershire sauce (most Worcestershire sauce manufacturers embrace anchovies or fish sauce).
• Garlic Powder & Paprika: These pack a punch of taste that complement this recipe completely.
• Ketchup: Ketchup provides a little bit of candy tomato taste to this mustard sauce recipe.

🍲 Ingredient Substitutions

• Brown Sugar And Honey: You need to use blackstrap molasses (take into account this can add darkish colours to your sauce) as an alternative of brown sugar, and cane sugar or agave syrup as an alternative of honey. Observe that for those who use cane sugar, typically it may be gritty within the sauce, so that you would possibly wish to cook dinner the sauce in a small pot over low warmth or medium warmth for 5-10 minutes to permit the sugar to soften.
• Vinegar: Should you don’t have apple cider vinegar, white vinegar works too.
• Worcestershire Sauce: Soy sauce is an effective different to worcestershire sauce.
• Garlic Powder And Paprika: Widespread spices are all you want for a wonderfully spiced recipe. Should you can’t dwell with out onion powder or chili powder, you possibly can add these too. Add ½ teaspoon of every earlier than whisking.
• Ketchup: Should you don’t like ketchup, you should utilize a bit little bit of tomato paste or purée as an alternative.

🔪 How To Make Mustard BBQ Sauce

This straightforward mustard BBQ sauce recipe comes along with a handful of elements, easy steps, and nearly no effort! Right here’s tips on how to make it:

Combine Substances Collectively: Stir all of the elements collectively in a mixing bowl till clean. A whisk helps incorporate the spices higher than a spoon or spatula.

How To Know When It’s Prepared: When it’s able to retailer, your sauce can have a pleasant golden coloration and can be fully mixed.

Refrigerate In a single day: Pour the golden sauce into an hermetic container or a glass jar. Resist the urge to drink it straight and place it within the fridge in a single day. You need to use it instantly however the flavors gained’t be as outstanding.

💭 Skilled Ideas

• Stick To Yellow Mustard: Dijon mustard is the flawed taste for this recipe, and stone floor mustard will make you mustard-based BBQ sauce grainy and gritty.
• Make Forward: Make this recipe prematurely, as a result of it tastes even higher the subsequent day!
• Style And Make Changes: Though the recipe tastes even higher the subsequent day, attempt it earlier than storing it. If you would like it a bit sweeter, add a bit extra brown sugar and honey. Should you change the recipe, write it down. I’ve a complete file of my very own variations of recipes I’ve tried.
• Pour Into Squeeze Bottles: For straightforward drizzling over sizzling canine, veggie canine, hamburgers, and extra!
• Double The Recipe: This recipe may be doubled for big teams.

📖 Variations

There’s many several types of BBQ sauce on the market, however mustard-based barbecue sauce is one in every of my favorites. Right here’s a number of variations to attempt:

• A Contact Of Warmth: Make a spicy mustard BBQ sauce with a splash of sizzling sauce, black pepper, cayenne pepper, crimson pepper flakes, or minced chipotle peppers in adobo sauce. Begin with a bit bit then add extra till you attain the specified warmth stage. A few of these are stronger than others; I’d use much less cayenne pepper to begin, for instance.
• Make It Smoky: Add some smoked paprika or a small quantity (like a half teaspoon to begin) of liquid smoke to this yellow bbq sauce recipe.
• Mustard BBQ Sauce With Honey Mustard: If you would like a sweeter sauce, attempt making BBQ honey mustard sauce by utilizing honey mustard rather than yellow mustard. You might wish to pull again on the quantity of sweetener added to this recipe, however style as you go!
• North Carolina BBQ Sauce: North Carolina vinegar BBQ sauce usually makes use of vinegar like apple cider vinegar as the bottom and no mustard.

🍽 Serving Options

Use this recipe for mustard BBQ sauce as a marinade or serve it on the desk as a condiment (or each!). Carry it to your subsequent gathering – it makes an excellent addition to any meal! Listed below are a number of of my favourite issues to take pleasure in this BBQ mustard sauce recipe with:

🙌 Dietary Variations

• Gluten-Free Possibility: Ensure to make use of an authorized gluten-free Worcestershire sauce.
• Vegan Possibility: Swap the honey for agave syrup and use vegan Worcestershire sauce!

🫙 Storage Instructions

• Refrigerating: Pour the sauce into an hermetic container like a jar with a tight-fitting lid. Refrigerate for as much as 2 weeks.
• Make Forward: In contrast to different sauces, mustard-style sauce solely will get higher the longer it sits. All of the flavors marry and deepen in taste. Make this superb sauce a minimum of 24 hours forward of time for one of the best taste.

❓Recipe FAQs

🔥 Extra BBQ Recipes!

📋 Recipe Card

🥘