Baby’s Only Formula Review | The Picky Eater

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure.

In this Baby’s Only Formula Review, I’m doing a deep dive into this popular organic formula – focusing on two of their infant formula options: Baby’s Only Premium Infant Formula and Baby’s Only Gentle Infant Formula. I’ll break down the key features, benefits, and differences between these two formulas to help simplify your decision-making process. Whether you’re a new parent or someone searching for the best formula for your baby, I’ve got you covered!

Navigating the journey of feeding your baby can be complex, and is so personal for every new parent. While breastfeeding stands as the initial recommendation, it’s just not always possible or realistic for all mothers to breastfeed – either exclusively, or at all. There can be so many different reasons why new parents may not be able to breastfeed, making formula feeding a viable and often necessary choice for many families. 

For me, transitioning my daughter to formula at 8 months was a difficult decision, but was so necessary for my mental and physical health! When I made the switch, it was important to me to find a formula that not only supported her developmental needs but also one that aligned with my values and expectations for quality and safety.

After consulting healthcare professionals, fellow parents, and diving deep into the infant nutrition space, I realized the importance of choosing a reputable and trustworthy brand. As a result, I have developed a working list of the best organic baby formulas that meet these guidelines. 

Good news: Baby’s Only Formula is one of the best options out there! Whether you’re a first-time parent looking for a formula that will meet your baby’s nutritional needs or you’re considering a switch to a formula that better suits your growing baby, Baby’s Only has a variety of options to meet your baby at every age and stage. It’s a great (and affordable!) choice for parents prioritizing organic ingredients and comprehensive nutrition for their child.

In this review I’ll dive deep into Baby’s Only Formula, highlighting what makes it distinct, summarizing insights from other parents, addressing common concerns, and more. Baby’s Only has a range of both infant formulas and toddler drinks, and for this review I’ll be focusing on two of their infant formulas: Baby’s Only Organic Complete Nutrition and Baby’s Only A2 Organic Milk.

By sharing this journey with you, I hope to ease the decision-making process, offering clarity and confidence in whether Baby’s Only is the right pick for your family. Let’s explore together!

But First, A Disclaimer

As a board-certified health coach and certified nutritionist, I support products and ingredients that are rooted in science and are evidence-based. Using my background in nutrition, along with extensive research (see below for details), consultations with experts, and my own personal experience giving my two kids formula, I have reviewed Baby’s Only Formula and recommend it highly. 

I may receive a commission (at no extra expense to you) if you purchase through the links provided. I only recommend brands that I have evaluated, believe are the highest quality, would give to my own two children, and that can do the most to help you and your family. By purchasing any of these products from the links below, you help keep this blog running, so thanks for your support!

Keep in mind that every baby & situation is different, especially yours, so please consult with your pediatrician first, especially when starting or switching to a new formula. My recommendations are not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Never disregard or delay in seeking professional medical advice because of something you read here!

The Verdict: Baby’s Only Is The Best Affordable, Organic American Made Infant Formula

When it comes to the best affordable, organic infant formula from the United States, Baby’s Only is one of the best formulas you can find. Not only are they one of the oldest American organic formula makers, their formula is free of GMOs, corn syrup solids, hexane-derived ingredients, added sugar, among other things!

Baby’s Only infant formula is easy to find at Target, and also has convenient subscription plans via their website (more on that below); making it easier to purchase and more affordable than many other organic brands. As you will see in this Baby’s Only review, there are many other reasons to love this high-quality and trustworthy US formula brand.

What Is Baby’s Only Formula? 

Baby’s Only was founded in 1999 and initially launched with America’s very first toddler formula – later developing their Premium/Complete Infant Formula, Pea Protein Toddler Formula, and Gentle Infant Formula lines. 

Their mission is to “make high-quality, organic baby formula accessible for every family.” I love this, because while organic formula is typically the cleaner choice for babies, it can be really expensive, and not all families can afford it. But parents shouldn’t have to choose a less-ideal option because they can’t afford the organic version – and that’s where Baby’s Only comes in! 

When I first started researching baby formulas (over 10 years ago!) – Baby’s Only hadn’t yet launched their infant formula – but I was still impressed by the ingredients in their toddler formula because of their commitment to organic ingredients, and the fact that every single one of their cans of formula are made right here at their headquarters in Ohio. 

One look at Baby’s Only formula ingredients, and you’ll know that you can feel good about feeding it to your little one: both infant formulas are made with organic lactose as the primary carbohydrate and first ingredient. 

​​Most importantly, Baby’s Only doesn’t contain any added sugars or glucose syrup, palm oil, hexane-extracted DHA, artificial flavors, or colors. Instead, it is made with only the good stuff that you’ll want when choosing a baby formula.

Their dedication to quality, safety, and variety makes Baby’s Only a standout choice for parents across the United States looking for the best for their babies.

What Types Of Formula Does Baby’s Only Make?

You’ll find a wide variety of formulas on Baby’s Only’s website, divided into infant formulas vs. toddler drinks, and regular vs. sensitive formulas. Baby’s Only is dedicated to creating formulas designed to meet different nutritional needs and preferences – so you can find the best fit for your baby.

Baby’s Only Infant Formulas Include:

Organic Complete Nutrition Infant Formula: One of the best organic baby formulas, crafted with high-quality ingredients. This formula is designed to closely mimic mature breast milk, providing essential nutrients, vitamins, and minerals for your baby’s development, and made with organic milk, lactose, and whey protein as the primary ingredients.

A2 Organic Milk Infant Formula: This formula is also modeled after mature breast milk, made with easy-to-digest A2 milk proteins for infants with more sensitive stomachs. Organic lactose, organic A2 nonfat milk, and organic whey protein are the primary ingredients here. Some studies suggest that A2 milk is easier to digest than A1 milk (which is used in the majority of infant formulas on the market today) (source). 

Baby’s Only Toddler Formulas Include:

Organic Dairy With Whey Toddler Drink: Made with organic nonfat milk and organic lactose, this is their classic dairy toddler drink with an extra helping of whey to support digestion. 

Organic Pea Protein Toddler Drink: This formula is 100% plant based! It’s a lactose-free, dairy-free, and soy-free formula for toddlers with lactose intolerance or cow’s milk protein allergy. This formula does use organic brown rice syrup as a carbohydrate source, as a replacement for the lactose found in their dairy toddler drink. 

Organic Sensitive DHA/ARA Toddler Drink: This soy-free toddler drink has reduced lactose, and is specially formulated to support lactose sensitivities. It also has DHA and ARA added for healthy omega 3 fats. This formula also uses brown rice syrup instead of lactose as the carbohydrate. 

Goat Milk DHA/ARA Toddler Formula: One of the best goat milk formulas, with easy-to-digest DHA, ARA, and naturally occurring prebiotics. Uses brown rice syrup as the main carbohydrate.

Baby’s Only Organic Complete Nutrition vs. Organic A2 Milk Infant Formula: What’s The Difference?

As you can see – Baby’s Only provides quite a few different formula varieties, so you really can find the best fit for your child. For this post, I’m going to dive deep into the two Baby’s Only infant formulas that are on the market today: their Organic Complete Nutrition, and their Organic A2 Milk Formula. 

Both options offer high-quality, organic nutrition tailored to your baby’s needs, but they come with distinct features that might make one more suitable for your little one than the other.

I’m going to give you a detailed overview of the ingredients, nutritional content, what makes each formula unique or better for certain babies and help you figure out which one could be the best pick for your child. Whether your baby has a sensitive tummy or you’re just trying to find the healthiest option, I’ve got the info to help you decide.

What Makes Baby’s Only Formula Different?

Long Track Record: Baby’s Only has been around for over 20 years, trusted by many parents as the top formula for their little ones. I love that they have a long track record of making affordable organic baby formulas right here in the United States. 

Domestic Manufacturing: Based in Ohio, they utilize domestic, in-house manufacturing for better control and oversight of the production process, and have extensive quality checks. You can have peace of mind knowing that this formula is closely monitored from sourcing to rigorous testing procedures! 

High Quality Ingredients: Not only does Baby’s Only meet USDA Organic regulations and is Non GMO, their infant formulas are created to be as similar to breast milk as possible, making them easy to digest and nutritionally complete for your baby. Not only that, their ingredients list is simple, including only a carbohydrate source (organic lactose as the first ingredient), milk proteins and whey (organic nonfat milk and organic whey), healthy fats (organic high oleic sunflower oil, soybean oil, and coconut oil), and vitamins and minerals.

Clean Label Project Purity Award: The Clean Label Project Purity Award is a recognition given by the Clean Label Project, a nonprofit organization focused on health and transparency in consumer product labeling. This award is granted to products that have been tested and  screened for over 130 harmful environmental and industrial contaminants and toxins, including heavy metals (like lead, arsenic, and mercury), pesticides, and chemicals used in the processing of certain plastics. I feel good knowing that Baby’s Only formulas meet these strict requirements!

Manufactured In The US: While I am a huge fan of European formulas, I believe that the more healthy, organic formulas we can get right here in the United States – the better it is for everyone! Baby’s Only produces all of their formula in their own state-of-the-art manufacturing facility, which means they have 100% control over their manufacturing, so they are completely on top of quality control of their formula.

Affordable: At $1.10 per oz for the larger organic premium infant formula can size, this is one of the most budget-friendly organic formulas you will find! I love that Baby’s Only puts their formula at a price point that makes it much more accessible to families and babies across the United States.

FDA Regulated: Because their formula is made in the United States, it is regulated by the FDA, which means that Baby’s Only must meet federal nutrient requirements and they must notify the FDA prior to marketing a new formula (source).

Drawbacks To Consider

Though there are many things that I love about Baby’s Only, there are admittedly a few drawbacks. Personally, I feel that the pros outweigh the cons, but it’s still important to consider the following: 

• Does not include added prebiotics or probiotics. But you can easily supplement with an infant probiotic if your pediatrician approves. I recommend Bobbie Probiotic Drops!
• Is not a hypoallergenic formula. Even though there is a gentle/A2 version, both of the infant formulas are still made with milk, and therefore may not be a good option for babies who cannot digest cow’s milk or have diagnosed CMPA.
• Does not contain DHA/ARA. This is also available via supplementation though!
• Only one stage. Unlike many European formulas which have different stages of formula for different ages of infants, Baby’s Only has just one stage for ages birth to 12 months. 
• Not intended for premature babies. Baby’s Only is formulated for full-term healthy babies. If you need a formula recommendation for your premature baby, speak with your baby’s doctor for the best choice for your little one.

Where Can I Buy Baby’s Only?

The easiest and most affordable way to purchase Baby’s Only Organic Infant Formula and/or their Organic Gentle Infant Formula is on their website as a one-time transaction, or you can sign up for their subscription service. When ordering, you have the option to purchase 1, 6, or 12 cans.

At this time of publication, they offer a discount of 15% off every recurring order when you set up a subscription purchase and allow you to modify, order more, pause, or cancel at any time, with no questions asked. 

But the great thing about Baby’s Only is that you can also find it in stores across America if you run out of formula unexpectedly! You can find both the premium infant formula and gentle infant formula at Target and Walmart.

How Much Does It Cost?

Baby’s Only will range from about $23-$28 for a 21 oz can as a one-time purchase, depending on whether you buy it at Target, Walmart or on their website. 

Cost of Baby’s Only Premium Infant Formula:

• Subscribe & Save on Baby’s Only Website: $24.64 for one 21-ounce can
• Target: $28.99 for one 21-ounce can
• Walmart: Available as a case of six 21-ounce cans, comes to $22.88 per can

Cost of Baby’s Only Gentle:

• Subscribe & Save on Baby’s Only Website: $26.34 for one 21-ounce can
• Target: $30.99 for one 21-ounce can
• Walmart: Available as a case of six 21-ounce cans, comes to $27.50 per can

What Do Parents Say About Baby’s Only? 

Easy On Digestion: “We’ve finally found a formula that works for us! Really Baby’s only organic formula works great for my daughter. We no long suffer from constant gassiness and fussiness. I love that it’s organic and clean formula with out ALOT of unnecessary ingredients. Highly recommend.” – Elizabeth

Great For Supplementing: “We supplement with formula and this worked really well for us to be able to order in a pinch. Is really easy on his tummy and mixes up well in the middle of the night when we are dead tired 😂 no complaints from him and none from us!” – Emily

Clean Ingredients: “I love the formulation of this infant formula. It has added iron and all the other basic vitamins needed to support a growing baby. I like that it is free of dyes and artificial coloring too. Great to have on hand, even if you plan on breast feeding since you never know if it is going to work out for you. This seems like the next best thing! Happy with this product!” – Jen

Modeled After Breastmilk: “A gentle formula that is easy on baby’s tummy. Its able to be digested, it has all the vitamins and supplements needed with no harsh ingredients. It is labeled that it is modeled after breastmilk. It is easy to scoop out and mix and directions are on the package haven’t had an issue. We have not had any issues since starting this just under 2 weeks ago and will continue to use it.” – Kelsey

How Does Baby’s Only Compare To Other American Formula Brands?

Baby’s Only vs. Earth’s Best

Baby’s Only and Earth’s Best are two companies dedicated to creating high-quality organic baby formula that’s manufactured in the US. 

Both of these infant formula brands are USDA organic and Non-GMO, and are free of syrup solids, added sugars, and artificial ingredients. 

The main differences between the two are: Baby’s Only doesn’t contain DHA, ARA, prebiotics or probiotics, while Earth’s Best contains DHA, ARA and prebiotics. Baby’s Only doesn’t contain palm oil, while Earth’s Best does. Earth’s Best is also slightly more expensive than Baby’s Only. Learn More: Baby’s Only vs. Earth’s Best

Baby’s Only vs. Similac

Baby’s Only and Similac are both long-standing American-made formulas. Both have no syrup solids or added sugar and use lactose as the primary carbohydrate source. Here are some of the main differences between Baby’s Only and Similac:

• Baby’s Only has a 60:40 whey-to-casein ratio (the same as breast milk), while Similac has a 48:52 whey-to-casein ratio, meaning that it may be harder on digestion. 
• Baby’s Only is also organic and non-GMO, while most of Similac’s formulas are not.
• Most of Similac’s formulas include pre/probiotics, while Baby’s Only does not, but you can always supplement!

Baby’s Only vs. Enfamil

Baby’s Only and Enfamil are both established baby formula brands that don’t have any added sugars and are made in the United States. Here are some of the key differences between the two formulas:

• Enfamil has a large variety of formulas to choose from. They offer a non-organic option and a non-GMO option. They used to have an organic version, but it has been out of stock for quite some time with no indication of when it will be back. But both of Baby’s Only’s infant formulas – the premium and gentle versions are organic and non-GMO.
• Enfamil contains palm oil, but Baby’s Only does not. 
• Enfamil contains DHA, but Baby’s Only does not.
• Enfamil is more expensive than Baby’s Only. Their flagship NeuroPro formula costs $1.73 per ounce. 
• Both mix well, but Enfamil has been reported to have a metallic taste.

Baby’s Only vs. Kendamil

Baby’s Only and Kendamil are both great formula companies, dedicated to providing high quality organic formula at an affordable price. Here are the main differences between the two:

• Baby’s Only is made exclusively in the US. Kendamil is made in the UK, but it was approved by the FDA to be sold in the United States as part of Operation Fly Formula during the 2022 formula shortage. 
• Baby’s Only’s infant formulas are all organic and non-GMO, but Kendamil has both a non-organic and an organic version (but both versions are made with milk from grass-fed cows). 
• Both formulas have no palm oil, no sugar or syrup solids.
• Both are also FDA regulated
• Kendamil is made with whole milk while Baby’s Only is made with nonfat milk. Kendamil also includes DHA, ARA, and prebiotics, while Baby’s Only does not.

Baby’s Only vs. Bobbie

These are another two amazing formula companies based in the US! I’m a huge fan of both Bobbie and Baby’s Only, and find them pretty comparable in terms of quality and commitment to providing the best for babies. Both are certified organic, non-GMO, and contain no sugar or syrup solids. Here are the main differences between the two:

• Bobbie contains DHA (meeting both US and EU standards), while Baby’s Only does not contain either.
• Bobbie is slightly more expensive than Baby’s Only, which is probably the most affordable organic infant formula I’ve found in the US.

Baby’s Only vs. Happy Baby

Baby’s Only and Happy Baby are both organic infant formulas, modeled after breast milk, that are made in the United States. Both also have a standard/complete infant formula and a gentle formula for more sensitive tummies. The differences are:

• Happy Baby contains DHA, ARA and prebiotics, while Baby’s Only does not
• Baby’s Only doesn’t contain palm oil, while Happy Baby does
• Happy Baby is more expensive than Baby’s Only
• Baby’s Only is widely available, while Happy Baby can be harder to find and/or can be out of stock.

Baby’s Only Formula FAQs

Final Thoughts

I hope this Baby’s Only infant formula review answered all your questions about Baby’s Only and helped you to decide if Baby’s Only formula is the right option for your little one! But before starting any formula, or if you ever have any questions about your child’s health and well-being, always consult their pediatrician as they will be able to guide you to the best decision. 

Overall, Baby’s Only is a fantastic American-made formula. It is made with clean ingredients, is organic and non-GMO, is a complete source of infant nutrition, is FDA-regulated and made according to the FDA dietary guidelines, and has a taste that babies love.

If you’re asking yourself, “Is Baby’s Only formula worth it?”, my answer would be yes! It’s absolutely worth it if it works for your baby, and it’s affordable which means it should be accessible for most budgets. If your baby is a full term infant, with no specific allergies or intolerances (e.g. CMPA or lactose intolerance), then Baby’s Only infant formula could be a great option for your child.

For more recipes, guides, tips, and tricks, check out the Best For Kids section of my blog. If you have any more questions about this product or brand or want to share your experience with Baby’s Only, please do so in the comments below or message me. I respond to every message I receive!